Calculation error - Crops: Known calculation errors of irrigation model

During the development of the new perennials pathway several calculation errors have been detected for the irrigation model.

For irrigation emissions both based on volume only and on volume, depth and distance, the reported % of area irrigated is not correctly calculating the respective energy used, but the Cool Farm Tool applies the % of area irrigated twice. This means there is an understatement of emissions in CFT 2.0, potentially significantly where % area is <100.
For emissions based on volume only, the area affects results when water added is indicated in volume (e.g. L). This is incorrect, as area shouldn't affect results for this calculation method for volume only.
Results for emissions based on volume, depth and distance are incorrect in CFT 2.0 due to a bug introduced during release - in CFT 1.0 the results were correct. The bug is likely in the unit conversion of fuel/energy emissions factors to kWh. Note: electricity is already in kWh and don't need the MJ conversion. Also, the kWh:L for diesel was probably broken in the update of energy density factors as part of the version release. This means CFT 2.0 is over reporting emissions due to the conversion - for electricity this is at least 3.6x too high.

We want our users to be aware of this. The errors will be fixed as part of the migration of the crop pathway to Cool Farm Platform.

Related Articles
Calculation error - All: Limestone fertiliser
There is an error with the fertiliser calculation which appears to be related to limestone. When you select limestone fertiliser and vary the unit selection you see that the soil/fertiliser emission amount in the results tab data table does not vary. ...
Cool Farm Tool 2.0 - Crops Data Input Table
Find attached a list of all data points required to complete a crop assessment in the Cool Farm Tool.
How do I classify 'hose and pump' irrigation systems?
Remember that details on irrigation are not required. This section only needs to be filled out if you want help from the tool in calculating the amount of energy use involved in irrigation (and therefore GHG). Since the Cool Farm Tool does not have ...
Calculation error - Crops: wood density calculated incorrectly
The wood density is incorrectly applied at least for the species listed below. This bug has existed since the excel version of the tool and will be fixed as part of the crop model migration to the new Cool Farm Platform. Inga punctuata Inga tonduzzi ...
Calculation error - Crops: underestimated emissions from crop residues for "removed from field"
Where the option ‘removed from field for use or sale’ is selected, the whole residue is assumed to be removed - this is incorrect. There should always be below ground emissions and a % of the above ground remaining - similar to "burning in field". ...

Related Articles